Skip to main content

An Alpha Confusion

DAY SIX in the impeachment trial of Chief Justice Renato Corona showed confusion in the court. And it centers on a tax reporting document that even Senate president Juan Ponce Enrile was not familiar of--the Alpha List. It is a list of single-income employees that their company submit to the Bureau of Internal Revenue (BIR) in lieu of an employee's individual filing of her annual income tax return (ITR).

Prosecution private lawyer Arthur Lim knew the Alpha List well enough; he got serious problem cross-examining the witness, BIR Commissioner Kim Jacinto-Henares, without touching on the issue of ill-gotten wealth that the Senate, acting as the Impeachment Court, ruled as inadmissible for presentation of evidence. He attempted to continue at least three time, stumbled into the non-issue again and again.

Defense lead counsel Serafin Cuevas was in his elements. He obviously knew what is an Alpha list is. But nevertheless strategically tried to throw the prosecution off the track. He volunteered to confirm as correct and no contest all the ITR that will be presented by the prosecution, obviously in an attempt to prevent presentation. And objected when the Alpha lists will be presented instead of the ITR.

What added most to the confusion was the obvious unfamiliarity of presiding judge Juan Ponce Enrile on what an Alpha list is. And from all indications, he was about to rule that the Alpha list will be prohibited from presentation. In fact, when Lim manifested that the lists cannot be lift in Court because they contain other names, Enrile ruled that "then the evidence are inadmissible to Court."

This is a hilarious situation to watch. The interlocutors seemed not to understand what's going on.

Then, Senator Ralph Recto, impatient on the drama unfolding, came to the rescue. He obviously knew what an Alpha list is. And he succeeded in getting through the confusion, directly asking the Henares questions in order to elicit information that Lim had serious problem of getting to.

The prosecutors of course were the one to blame on this. Lim simply failed to effectively lay grounds for his cross-examination of Henares. Had he asked the witness to clarify confusion on the Alpha list, the confusion could have been prevented. In my mind, at day six of the trial, the prosecution are still fumbling in their presentation, even if practicing trial lawyers tried to help.

In situations like this, prosecutors are expected to have clear and well-organized logic to guide effectively the minds of the Filipino people in a way that makes the presentation of evidence easy to understand. No one can blame the defense; it is their job to muddle the issue in order to get a negative ruling on the articles deliberated.

At the end of the day, an evidence is useless if it cannot be presented to the Court, and done so convincingly.
Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Gifts of Discounts

SECTION 13 of the New Code of Philippine Judicial Conduct (27 April 2004) stated: Judges and members of their families shall neither ask for nor receive any gift, bequest, loan, or favor in relation to anything done or to be done or omitted to be done by him or her in connection with the performance of judicial duties. Its annotation explains that: Public officials and employees shall not solicit or accept, directly or indirectly, any gift, gratuity, favor, entertainment, loan or anything of money value from any person in the course of their official duties or in connection with any operation being regulated by, or any transaction which may be affected by the functions of their office." The key phrase here is--"in the course of their official duties." It means that as long as a judge remains a judge of Philippine courts, this Code applies, prohibiting any receipt, directly or indirectly, from any person. The question then is: Is a discount a gift? ...
Post a Comment
Read more

Substate-of-a-Gun

THE MORO ISLAMIC Liberation Front (MILF) boldly declared that Muslims be allowed to run their government even "if they go to hell by their own making, so be it." I go for a lasting peace in Muslim Mindanao; but I have serious doubts on real peace when these armed Muslim leaders cannot accept the fact of life that Mindanao is no longer a Muslim territory after Muslim settlers took the land from the Lumads in the prehistoric Philippines. I came from Zamboanga, and grew there. Despite MILF's claim of representing the dream of Muslims in Mindanao, I have serious doubts if the leaders are merely using this separatist slogan for their own aggrandizement. Look at ARMM under MNLF's Nur Misuari who had nothing to show for the tax shares it received from the government. And reports had it Misuari kept a huge sum from this money for his own accounts. So I have so much reservations on the lasting peace settlement with the MILF can bring. First, how much really of our Muslim si...
Post a Comment
Read more

The Catholic-Ivory Connection

THE ENORMOUS FIGURES of seized ivory smuggled "through" the Philippines--5.4 tons in 2009; 6.1 tons from China in 2006; 7.7 tons in 2005--prove the huge market of ivory in the country. It may be argued as a mere transhipment affair; but from all indications, it may not be so alone (why in the first place would smugglers from China passes through the Philippines? Does that make Philippine shipments to China safe by reputation?). By these figures alone we can surmise that these smuggling activities happen year in and out. With 2007 and 2008 reporting no cease or seizing of shipments, you can only presume that the supplies reached their intended receivers. I noticed in Brian Cristy's National Geographic article "Ivory Worship"  the perceivable excitement in the Catholic clerics he interviewed when speaking about the ivory icons. The reports from icon-makers in Manila on the regularity of Catholic clerics, religious and laity in their shops to purchase icons...
Post a Comment
Read more